I collected over 28 lists of the Best Movies/Films of 2017 from the Internet, magazines and newspapers and combined them into one meta-list. Here are the results: all the movies on three or more of the original source lists, organized by rank (that is, with the movies on the most lists at the top).
Note: These are not my personal opinions. I have not watched all these movies. If I have seen one of the films, I have included my 1-10 rating.
On 28 lists
Get Out (US, Jordan Peele) (8/10)
On 27 lists
Lady Bird (US, Greta Gerwig) (9/10)
Call Me by Your Name (Italy/US, Luca Guadagnino)
On 21 lists
The Florida Project (US, Sean Baker) (10/10)
On 19 lists
Dunkirk (UK, Christopher Nolan) (8/10)
On 17 lists
Phantom Thread (US, Paul Thomas Anderson) (9/10)
On 16 lists
The Shape of Water (US, Guillermo del Toro)
On 15 lists
Faces Places (France, Agnès Varda & JR) (8/10)
On 14 lists
Good Time (US, Benny & Josh Safdie)
The Big Sick (US, Michael Showalter) (7/10)
On 12 lists
A Ghost Story (US, David Lowery) (8/10)
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri (US/UK, Martin McDonagh)
On 10 lists
BPM (Beats Per Minute) (France, Robin Campillo)
Mudbound (US, Dee Rees) (8/10)
On 9 lists
Wonder Woman (US/China, Patty Jenkins)
A Quiet Passion (UK, Terence Davies)
The Meyerowitz Stories (New and Selected) (US, Noah Baumbach) (7/10)
On 8 lists
mother! (US, Darren Aronofsky)
Dawson City: Frozen Time (US, Bill Morrison)
The Lost City of Z (US, James Gray)
Okja (South Korea/US, Bong Joon-ho)
Columbus (US, Kogonada)
Personal Shopper (France, Olivier Assayas) (7/10)
On 7 lists
The Disaster Artist (US, James Franco)
A Fantastic Woman (Chile, Sebastián Lelio)
On 6 lists
God’s Own Country (UK, Francis Lee)
On 5 lists
Blade Runner 2049 (US/UK, Denis Villeneuve)
I Am Not Your Negro (France/US, Raoul Peck)
Baby Driver (UK/US, Edgar Wright) (7/10)
War for the Planet of the Apes (US, Matt Reeves)
The Post (US, Steven Spielberg)
Graduation (Romania, Cristian Mungiu)
Detroit (US, Kathryn Bigelow)
On 4 lists
Ex Libris: New York Public Library (US, Frederick Wiseman)
I Called Him Morgan (Sweden/US, Kasper Collin)
Lady Macbeth (UK, William Oldroyd)
Logan Lucky (US, Steven Soderbergh)
Thor: Ragnarok (US, Taika Waititi)
Raw (France/Belgium, Julia Ducournau)
Twin Peaks: The Return (TV series) (US, David Lynch)
Norman: The Moderate Rise and Tragic Fall of a New York Fixer (US/Israel, Joseph Cedar)
Kedi (Turkey, Ceyda Torun)
Logan (US, James Mangold)
Wonderstruck (US, Todd Haynes)
Marjorie Prime (US, Michael Almereyda)
On 3 lists
Thelma (Norway, Joachim Trier)
Their Finest (UK, Lone Scherfig)
Girls Trip (US, Malcolm D. Lee)
Professor Marston & The Wonder Women (US, Angela Robinson)
Song to Song (US, Terence Malick)
Jane (US, Brett Morgen)
Foxtrot (Israel, Samuel Maoz)
Princess Cyd (US, Stephen Cone)
The Other Side of Hope (Finland, Aki Kaurismäki)
Wind River (US, Taylor Sheridan)
Your Name (Japan, Makoto Shinkai)
It (US, Andy Muschietti)